October 1847 is the first time Pleasant Grove is listed in the minutes of Ohio Presbytery. Therefore it was organized sometime prior to this date.

1847
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - William McCoy
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 19-20, 1847, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1848
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - James Canada
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, March 23-24, 1848, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1848
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 17-18, 1848, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1849
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - G. Dowel
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, March 29-31, 1849, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1849
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 22-24, 1849, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1849
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, December 4-5, 1849, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1851
Pleasant Grove not listed.
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 17-18, 1851]

1852
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, March 11-12, 1852, page 1 of loose manuscript minutes]

1852
Pleasant Grove not listed.
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 18-19, 1852]

1853
Pleasant Grove not listed.
[Source: Minutes of Ohio Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 7-9, 1853]

No Minutes for Ohio Presbytery in archives for 1854-1872

1873
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - Davis Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 12 & 14, 1873, page 1]

1873
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 11 & 13, 1873, page 10]

1874
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 11 & 13, 1874, page 20]

1874
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 10 & 12, 1874, page 31]

1875
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 10 & 12, 1875, page 41]

1875
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - M. L. Dowell
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 6 & 8, 1875, page 51]

1876
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 4 & 6, 1876, page 69]

1877
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - W. L. Dowell
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 7 & 9, 1877, page 83]

1877
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 20 22-23, 1877, page 93]

1878
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - W. W. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 6 & 8, 1878, page 108]

1878
Pleasant Grove not in list.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 2 & 4, 1878, page 128]

1879
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - J. W. Dowell
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 12 & 14, 1879, page 144]

1879
Nolin Presbytery met at Pleasant Grove Church, Breckinridge County, Ky, on the 15th day of July 1879.
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, July 15, 1879, page 154]

1879
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - W. W. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 1 & 3, 1879, page 180]

1880
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - John Haynes
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 13, 15-16, 1880, page 190]

1881
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 9 & 11, 1881, page 202]

1881
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, September 10 & 12, 1881, page 211]

1882
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 8 & 10, 1882, page 218]

1882
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - W. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 7 & 9, 1882, page 227]

1883
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 7 & 9, 1883, page 1]

1883
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 13 & 15, 1883, page 13]

1884
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - W. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 12 & 14, 1884, page 22]

1884
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - J. Y. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 1 & 3, 1884, page 30]

1885
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - E. D. Legrand
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 30-31, 1885, page 42]

1886
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - J. Y. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 5, 1886, page 57]

1887
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - John Y. Nichols
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 4-5 & 7, 1887, page 70]

1888
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - John W. Dowell
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 2-3 & 5, 1888, page 83]

1889
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - John W. Dowell
[Source: Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 1-5 , 1889, page 102]

1890
Name of the Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: John H. Legrand, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: E. R. Duggin
Total Membership: 41
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1890, page 186]

1890
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 31-November 3, 1890, page 1]

1891
Name of the Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: John H. Legrand, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: none listed
Total Membership: not given
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1891, page 202]

1891
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 1-5, 1891, page 1]

1892
No Reports from Nolin Presbytery.

1892
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, November 3-5, 1892, page 3]

1893
Name of the Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: John H. Legrand, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: T. Richardson
Total Membership: 20
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1893, page 212]

1893
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 24-26, 1893, page 1]

1894
Name of the Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: John H. Legrand, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: none listed
Total Membership: not given
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1894, page 224]

1895
Name of the Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: A. Bruner, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: H. C. Hook
Total Membership: 70
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1895, page 234]

1895
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove - A. A. Bruner
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 25-28, 1895, page 2]

1896
Name of Congregation: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: A. A. Bruner, Garfield, Ky.
Pastor: H. C. Hook
No. Communicants: 70
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1896, page 213]

1896
Elder representative from Pleasant Grove - J. W. Dowell
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, September 4-9, 1896, page 1]

1897
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Dowell, J. C., Garfield, Ky.
Minister: Hook, H. C.
No. Communicants: not given
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1897, page 179]

1897
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Nolin Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, September 3-6, 1897, page 2]

1898
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: A. H. Bruner, Garfield, Ky.
Minister: J. A. Bozarth
No. Communicants: not given
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1898, page 199]

1898
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Owensboro Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 9-10, 1898, page 2]

1899
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: A. H. Brewner, Garfield, Ky.
Minister: J. A. Bozarth
No. Communicants: 40
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1899, page 95a]

1899
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
[Minutes of Owensboro Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 3-5, 1899]

No minutes of Owensboro Presbytery for 1900 in archives.

1900
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: A. H. Brewner, Garfield, Ky.
Minister: none listed
No. Communicants: 40
Nolin Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1900, page 114a]

1901
No elder representative from Pleasant Grove congregation.
Committee on Pastorates and Supplies
Pleasant Grove - Rev. J. A. Bozarth, salary $4.50 per trip.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, April 23-25, 1901, page 8]

1901
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Lydia Dowell, Garfield, Ky.
Minister In Charge: J. A. Bozarth
Total No. of Members: 45
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1901, page 138a]

1901
Elder Representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - Harry Kennedy
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, October 8-9, 1901, page 1]

1902
Name of Church: Pleasant Grove
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Mrs. Lydia Dowell, Garfield, Ky.
Minister In Charge: J. A. Bozarth
Total No. of Members: 56
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1902, page 128a]

1902
Elder Representative from Pleasant Grove congregation - J. W. Webb
"By request of the congregation the name of Pleasant Grove was changed from that of Pleasant Grove to Garfield, and on motion T. A. Gray, J. W. Webb and G. H. Kennedy was appointed a committee to sell the old Pleasant Grove Church property and to use the proceeds in building a new church house in the town of Garfield, Kentucky."
The Committee on Pastors and Supplies read the following report which was adopted: Pleasant Grove wants Rev. N. G. Cundiff.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 5-7, 1902, pages 1, 2 & 8]

1903
Name of Church: Garfield
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Hiram Durbin, Garfield, Ky.
Minister Now In Charge: N. G. Cundiff
Total Number of Members: 70
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1903, page 113a]

1903
Elder Representative from Garfield Congregation - H. Durbin
Report No. 2 of the Committee on Pastorates and Supplies was read and adopted, as follows:
Ephesus, Garfield, Providence, Taylor's Chapel and Short Creek desire the ministerial services of Rev. N. G. Cundiff for the ensuing year.
A committee appointed at the last meeting of this Presbytery to sell the church property known as Pleasant Grove, reported as follows:
We, your committee, would report that owing to other claims against said property, have failed to sell, and respectfully ask advice of this body.
The above report was received and committee retained, with instructions to advise with legal counsel and dispose of said property as best they can. T. A. Gray, J. W. Webb, G. H. Kennedy.
T. A Gray offered his resignation as a member of the above committee, which was received, and J. W. Webb was made chairman of the same.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 4, 1903, pages 3, 13-14 & 16-17]

1904
Name of Church: Garfield
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Hiram Durbin, Garfield, Ky.
Minister Now In Charge: N. G. Cundiff
Total Number of Members: 98
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1904, page 96a]

1904
Elder representative from Garfield - V. B. Mattingly
Pleasant Grove Church Property
The committee appointed at last meeting of Presbytery to dispose of Pleasant Grove church property was asked to make report of their work at next meeting of Presbytery.
The Following Report of Committee on Pastorates and Supplies Adopted.
Ephesus, Garfield, Freedom and Short Creek desire the services of Rev. N. G. Cundiff.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 9-12, 1904, pages 3, 9 & 10]

1905
Name of Church: Garfield
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Hiram Durbin, Garfield, Ky.
Minister Now In Charge: N. G. Cundiff
Total Number of Members: 116
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1905, page 77a]

1905
Elder representative from Garfield - J. W. Webb
Report of Committee to dispose of the Pleasant Grove Church property: "We your Committee appointed to sell the Pleasant Grove Church property and use the proceeds in the erection of a new Church House at Garfield, would report that we have sold said property and used the proceeds as directed."
Report of Committee on Pastors and Supplies
Garfield congregation desires the services of Rev. N. G. Cundiff, compensation $100.00.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 8-11, 1905, pages 1, 2 & 10]

1906
Name of Church: Garfield
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Hiram Durbin, Garfield, Ky.
Minister Now In Charge: N. G. Cundiff
Total Number of Members: 128
Leitchfield Presbytery - Kentucky Synod
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1906, page 68a]

1906
Elder representative from Garfield - J. W. Webb
Committee on Pastors and Supplies
Garfield, Freedom, Clifton, Providence, Mt. Vernon and Ephesus desire the services of Rev. N. G. Cundiff. Compensation--Garfield, $100.
[Source: Minutes of Leitchfield Presbytery of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, August 7-10, 1906, pages 2 & 10]

Garfield, Ky.--It was my pleasure to attend the protracted meeting at Garfield which has just closed, with splendid results. It lasted ten days, with Rev. B. T. Watson doing the preaching. His sermons were full of spiritual instruction for the Christian and just the kind to convince and convict the unconverted ones who came to hear him. I have never attended a series of meetings that did me more good. The visible results were twenty converts, all of whom united with the church. This is the first protracted meeting Garfield congregation has had in their new house of worship. This is a splendid structure, and will be dedicated in the near future free of debt.--G. W. St. Clair.
[Source: The Cumberland Presbyterian, December 10, 1903, page 759]

Garfield, Ky.--Rev. J. C. Cundiff writes that the new church here is nearing completion and will be dedicated May 29, when he will be assisted by Rev. B. T. Watson. Mr. Watson conducted a meeting for this congregation in December, which resulted in great good.
[Source: The Cumberland Presbyterian, May 5, 1904, page 567]